Macallan Classic Cut Limited 2023 Edition

Macallan

WB 86.7 173 оценок 50.3 %vol

exBourbon + Sherry seasoned Whiskybase

Бочки созревания/финиша

Выдержка Ex-Bourbon & Sherry seasoned · Whiskybase (Cask Type) · 2026-09-13T06:05:41Z WB ↗

Магазинов с предложением: 1 · предложений: 1 · в наличии: 1 · цена: от 103.89 €

S3: собрано индивидуальных оценок 174 из 174

карточка Whiskybase

Отзывы Whiskybase

учтено 37 заметок · текстовых 26 · полный lossless-снимок WB (полнота подтверждена)

Суммаризация отзывов

Отзывы о Macallan Classic Cut 2023 расходятся: одни находят его приятным и насыщенным, другие — простым и не выдающимся. Чаще отмечают доминирование бурбона, ваниль, фруктовость и специи.

развернуть подробно

В отзывах неоднократно подчёркивается, что в этом виски преобладает влияние бурбоновых бочек, а шерри почти не ощущается. Нос описывают как сладкий и фруктовый, с ванилью, карамелью, грушей, яблоком, цитрусом, а также ореховыми и шоколадными нотами; во вкусе упоминают ваниль, карамель, дубовую специю, имбирь, сухофрукты, изюм, молочный шоколад и орехи. Финиш в разных отзывах оценивают по-разному — от округлого и среднего до длинного, пряного и дубового, иногда с горечью или коротким послевкусием. Часть отзывов отмечает, что виски требует времени в бокале, чтобы раскрыться и стать более гармоничным, а крепость ощущается заметно. Мнения о качестве расходятся: некоторые считают его значительно лучше ожидаемого для современного Macallan, приятным и насыщенным, с хорошей маслянистостью; другие называют его простым, нейтральным по характеру спирта, неоправданно дорогим или лишённым сложности, а один отзыв прямо говорит, что он не имеет ничего общего с профилем, сделавшим Macallan известным. Несколько отзывов упоминают, что добавление воды делает вкус более пряным или разваливает фруктовость.

собрано 26/37 текстовых отзывов · полный lossless-снимок WB · 2026-10-08T06:59:08Z · источник evidence

greatcircle_telepr Member Senior 90 24 sep 2023 2:39 pm

Something really special. Everybody will like this :)

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	Sweet vanilla and fruity.
Вкус	90	No doubt that this has aged in Bourbon casks. The taste really shines through, not overly sweet but pleasant.
Финиш	91	Round and subtle.

springtank Connoisseur 84 26 jun 2025 5:32 pm

Green, floral, wet grass, sherry flavor is not obvious, and there is a slight sense of alcohol. It gets a little better after the cup is awakened. The aroma is good and the bitterness is gone.

нос 86 · вкус 84 · финиш 83

Dirac Connoisseur 86 06 feb 2026 2:57 pm

RMB 699/bottle. That's a good price for a Macallan.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	85	Standard sherry flavor.
Вкус	87	Not bad. Oily and moisturizing.
Финиш	86	For this alcohol content, the aftertaste is a bit short.

Stefan_Hartl Expert Senior 84 26 feb 2026 5:54 pm

In this Macallan, the bourbon casks clearly predominate. The malt is fruity and fresh with plenty of oak spice. Overall, somewhat unspectacular.

paulsamra Member Senior 81 20 jan 2025 7:11 pm

I enjoy this expression. It’s like a CS and better version version of the 12 triple casks. Actually I am not too into Macallan bourbon cask stuff but this class cut is quite good to enjoy.

junyvyao Connoisseur 86 24 jan 2025 12:39 pm

Sweet Pear, Elderflower, Almond

нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86

hs305 Connoisseur 78 06 may 2025 10:16 pm

[May 2025] Despite knowing that I do not like the modern Macallan for more than a decade now, a friend gave me a small sample of this... ...and no, it did not change my mind. Actually, this has absolutely nothing to do with the profile that made Macallan once famous. This is a completely different malt, and of average quality only (at best). To be honest, why should I invest some of my precvious liver cells to swallow this stuff? Do not get me wrong, if you like this dram this is absolutely fine - simply because "there is no accouting on taste" and everybody should savour what he/she likes. It is just: I drank a lot of the old Macallan before, and this ruined my senses for such a modern style dram - sorry, folks.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	79	There is nothing noteworthy in here, this smells like any other young modern malt. Given this nose I guess this dram is not much older than 5-6 years.
Вкус	79	There is nothing noteworthy in the taste either, this tastes like any other young modern malt. I guess this dram is not much older than 5-6 years.
Финиш	75	Both the mouthfeel and the finish are almost non-existent, hence the texture (quality) of the spirit is rather poor. I used the spittoon.

TribleB Expert Senior 88 16 apr 2026 9:50 am

Significantly better than expected for a modern Macallan.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	88	Milk chocolate, Oloroso soy sauce, balsamic vinegar, fig, dates, pickles
Вкус	89	Milk chocolate, oak spice, cocoa, butter, crème brûlée, puffed rice The alcohol is very well integrated, resulting in a very smooth mouthfeel.
Финиш	87	Creamy, chocolatey, sweet - medium length

Medix Expert Senior 85 20 oct 2023 11:37 am

нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 85

maltaholic Connoisseur 89 12 nov 2023 4:59 pm

It smells noble, intense ex-bourbon barrel, with floral and fruity notes. There is gooseberry, kiwi, no sherry, some vanilla and wonderfully delicate wood. It goes on like this in the mouth, only that he gets strong very quickly - no, really strong! He's got a lot of bang! But he remains mature and elegant, the alcohol doesn't overwhelm you. The taste is a touch spicier, woodier. But overall really good!

нос 89 · вкус 90 · финиш 88

bakerman Connoisseur 86 08 dec 2025 8:00 pm

Fruity and nutty, although a little simple altogether.

нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85

Angulo04 Member Senior 87 17 aug 2026 5:00 pm

This is a whisky that definitely needed time for me to appreciate. My first impression wasn't very positive, but now I really like it. It's strong, spicy, and intense, but with enough time in the glass, it's significantly more harmonious and complex than I initially expected.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	87	Initially somewhat closed and alcoholic. With more time in the glass, the orange, vanilla, caramel, and dark fruit flavors come through much more clearly. There are also some spice and oak notes.
Вкус	86	Strong and intense. Sweet fruits, caramel, spices, and a hint of chocolate. Initially, it was almost too sharp and unsettled for me, but after a while, it becomes significantly smoother and truly powerful.
Финиш	87	Long and warm with spicy oak, dark fruit, and a touch of sweetness. The strength of the 50.3% ABV remains noticeable without becoming unpleasant.

ezmaster147 Member Junior 90 19 oct 2023 10:37 pm

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89
Вкус	91	almond chocolate, dried fruit, Sweet and creamy vanilla, delicate oak
Финиш	89

90ClubWhisky Connoisseur 86 22 jun 2025 9:23 pm

Golden color. Oily structure.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	87	Quite intense and sweet. This time, surprisingly, the influence of the Bourbon barrels comes out. Lots of vanilla. Caramel. Vanilla pudding. A hint of citrus underneath. Coconut. Coconut flakes. Bounty bar. A hint of spice. Pickled ginger.
Вкус	86	Lots of vanilla. Caramel. Coconut. Milk chocolate. Bounty bar. Gets drier. Oak. Walnut. Spices. Cinnamon. Pickled ginger. Some oiliness. Cocoa. Dark chocolate. Light spiciness.
Финиш	86	Coconut. Milk chocolate. Caramel. Vanilla. Spices. Cinnamon. White pepper. Ginger. Quite a pronounced spiciness. Oak. Hazelnuts. Cocoa. Dark chocolate. Dark chocolate. Coffee with a bit of milk but no sugar. Quite a long finish.

katarn_rb Connoisseur 87 07 feb 2026 9:35 pm

Floral, vanilla, caramel and apple with cinnamon. Bourbon is in the foreground, I hardly notice the sherry.

whisky_oberlahn Expert Senior 87 25 apr 2026 10:09 pm

нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 86

90ClubWhisky Connoisseur 86 19 sep 2023 7:33 pm

Golden color. Oily structure.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	85	Dried fruits. Raisins. Hazelnut. Milk chocolate with raisins. Delicacies. Spices. Ginger. Cinnamon. Lots of raisins. On the second nose, more intensely. More milk chocolate. Even nougat makes an appearance.
Вкус	87	Quite intense. A lot of dried fruit. Raisins. Hazelnuts. Dessert chocolate with dried fruit. Lots of nuts. Cocoa. Spices. Ginger. Oranges loom underneath. Slight oiliness. On the second sip, a little more fresh fruit at the beginning. Oranges appeared.
Финиш	86	Hazelnuts. Dried fruits. Dessert chocolate. Cocoa. Spices. Ginger. A bit of oak. Raisins. Dessert chocolate with hazelnuts. Lots of cocoa. After the second sip, a lot more spice at the beginning. Delicate spiciness. Quite intense and long finish.

Gino85 Newbie — 01 feb 2025 12:51 am

Goede prijs/kwaliteit

szligen Expert Senior 84 06 jan 2026 4:16 am

нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 82

Chesterking Expert Senior 86 07 jan 2026 6:52 am

zzqfyl Connoisseur 85 17 sep 2023 3:19 pm

нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 85

Gold_Savourer Newbie 87 10 nov 2023 10:07 pm

Really good new Macallan 2023. I buy every Macallan Classic Cut because I really like these expressions. The 2021 and 2022 were more like sweet bakery and candy floss but the 2023 bears more fruity aromas like pear and fresh apple. On the tongue there is a strong accession with sweet spicy oak which developes with a short shift to a slightly bitter ginger remanence. It takes some drops of water to emerge additional aromas. It gets better with every sip.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	86	light sweetness, vanilla, apple, pear, yeast dough
Вкус	87	sweet, spice, oak, ginger, strong appearance
Финиш	87	long, spicy, adstringent

SwiftyMcVeigh Expert Senior 87 26 jan 2024 3:07 pm

The ex-bourbon influence is in the foreground. Nice to drink, it lacks the complexity for a higher rating. I like the nose best. Water is not recommended as it makes it too spicy on the palate for me. The structure also suffers.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	89	Ripe pear, almond oil, vanilla, blossom honey, elderberry. Toffee. Beeswax. Ripe orange. Very nice nose!
Вкус	86	Oily start. Orange, pear, grapefruit, vanilla, ginger and oak spice. Honey. malt sugar. Bright grapes. The alcohol pushes the flavors forward, but is well integrated. Based on the nose, I expected a little more. I think there are some young barrels, but also older ones up to 12 years old. With water it becomes too spicy for me and the fruit falls apart.
Финиш	85	oak, ginger. Honey. Becomes drier. Medium length.

DrOmega Expert Senior 80 11 feb 2024 2:16 pm

Remarkably sweet and candy, gives a full and warm feeling. Separate reflection of fruit and wood tones, but perhaps missing a slightly 'fresher' component to complete the whole.

Saruman Newbie 89 12 oct 2023 10:51 pm

Tasty but not overwhelming

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	88	Dried fruit, chocolate
Вкус	89	Dried fruit, raisins, orange, honey
Финиш	89	Orange, chocolate, figs

Heemhoeve Expert Senior 88 01 nov 2023 10:06 pm

Nice nose, especially the pear/vanilla combination is balanced.

Sweetspot Connoisseur 86 22 nov 2023 9:04 am

нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 84

Mobidick Expert Junior 88 29 aug 2024 8:18 pm

нос 88 · вкус 87 · финиш 88

valasios Connoisseur 86 13 dec 2023 1:43 pm

нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 85

The_Osprey Expert Senior 84 25 mar 2024 12:11 am

Macallan Classic Cut, SMSW 50.3%. 30ml sample from Mr Dram Man consumed Feb 2024. Dark golden yellow. Aroma is quite muted. Some pleasant simple vanilla and biscuity oak. Malted milk biscuits. Hint of margarine. Very simple. I like American oak but it does need to be first fill or aged a longer time than this is in order to impart its best characteristics. This is clean but too basic. The spirit character is very neutral. Below-average on the aroma. Nice oiliness to the body. Taste is pretty good. Could almost be a mid-aged grain whisky given the neutrality of the spirit and the oak-led flavour. Not complex on the palate either but definitely a bit better in that department than the aroma. Has a nice richness to it. Vanilla and sweet oak extract, vague biscuit and crème brulee notes and the faintest, faintest orange but mostly just delivering that rich vanilla American oak. Faint bitterness on the finish but nothing too distracting. The body is probably the best thing about this. A good solid dram but a similar or better experience can be had while saving some cash. 3.5/84-

realcjames Member Senior 86 29 nov 2025 2:40 pm

It has flavor, but the alcohol content is overwhelming; it's just okay.

Whiskyfin Member Senior — 05 sep 2023 4:40 pm

SingleMaltRussell Expert Senior 85 25 apr 2025 6:22 pm

Some very nice malt showing in the midpalate and not much sherry at all, so I probably couldn’t ask for a Macallan built more along the lines of what I tend to enjoy. Solid stuff this, with the obligatory disclaimer that it still, in no way justifies the purchase price.

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	84	Lemon barley sugars and orange cream soda become baked stone fruit in pastry, rose Turkish delight, candied almonds with maybe a hint of tropical passionfruit
Вкус	86	Texturally medium-thick, amber honey and butter mature into somewhat darker and denser crème caramel, with toffee malt becoming toffee apple surrounded by a bubbly gaggle of mixed peppercorns
Финиш	85	Heavily driven by oak char notes. Creme caramel turns to Creme brûlée and the burnt sugars start to pick up a coffee bean bitterness. The peppers settle down to icy/hot eucalyptus and szechuan oils poured over pebbles

TechnOBY Connoisseur 82 27 apr 2025 1:07 am

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	82	some bourbon, but rather flat
Вкус	82	very malty, dry, slightly bitter
Финиш	83	malty, dry, quite long

Richard1969 Member Senior 92 16 dec 2023 10:51 pm

нос 89 · вкус 91 · финиш 90

Capodonich Connoisseur 88 27 jun 2024 12:16 pm

нос 87 · вкус 88 · финиш 88

Whisky_dan Expert Senior 88 09 dec 2025 8:01 pm

нос · вкус · финиш

Нос	88	Bright fruity, lots of vanilla, caramel candy, nicely balanced, slightly perfumed.
Вкус	88	Lots of oak spice, cocoa, leather armchair, caramel, strong
Финиш	87	The woody notes linger, with a medium-long finish.

Оценки по участникам WB

собранные 86.6 среднее по всем сохранённым наблюдениям; WB-рейтинг не заменяется

снимок #14320 · статус complete · собран 2026-09-01T15:18:38+00:00 · сверено: строки сходятся с объявленным числом · ожидалось 174, фактических строк 174, сохранено 174

экспертный allowlist: Expert Junior, Expert Senior, Specialist, Connoisseur. Служебные роли (Administrator, Community Manager, Editor, Photo Moderator, Shoplink Moderator, Super Administrator) остаются ролью, но экспертизой не объявляются. Авторское смещение не применяется: author-bias correction not applied; view is raw observations.

показано 50 из 174 · страница 3 из 4 · за страницей ещё 124

Одно наблюдение = одна строка исходной таблицы; повторные оценки одного автора сохраняются. «Дата неизвестна» означает отсутствие даты в источнике, а не время сбора.
Автор	Роль WB	Эксперт	Оценка	Дата	Наблюдение
2791knarf	Connoisseur	да	87.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #100
Sweetspot	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #101
bakerman	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #102
mrmephisto	Expert Senior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #103
valasios	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #104
realcjames	Member Senior	нет	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #105
Machiavel	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #106
wbarchive_526950	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #107
Chesterking	Expert Senior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #108
Welmer	Expert Junior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #109
Sir_Islay	Expert Junior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #110
Bixbyit	Expert Senior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #111
Baanaanaabob	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #112
90ClubWhisky	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #113
Medix	Expert Senior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #114
junyvyao	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #115
tombom72	Member Senior	нет	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #116
gordonkwong	Expert Senior	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #117
Sir Mac	Member Senior	нет	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #118
Izzino	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #119
Butze83	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #120
Dirac	Connoisseur	да	86.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #121
IlValentino	Member Senior	нет	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #122
SingleMaltAddicted	Expert Junior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #123
Tijmen	Super Administrator	нет	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #124
Pulky1986	Expert Junior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #125
zzqfyl	Connoisseur	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #126
ragnar	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #127
OKoster	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #128
Jonas_S	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #129
Medix	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #130
Thingol	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #131
wwffwwwwf	Expert Junior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #132
ALUM	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #133
el Gato	Connoisseur	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #134
SingleMaltRussell	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #135
whiskyexperte	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #136
Glengoolie	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #137
OKoster	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #138
NicomoCosca	Expert Senior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #139
mauro82	Expert Junior	да	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #140
MRoursgaard	Member Senior	нет	85.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #141
macko	Member Junior	нет	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #142
szligen	Expert Senior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #143
Stefan_Hartl	Expert Senior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #144
springtank	Connoisseur	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #145
The_Osprey	Expert Senior	да	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #146
Philomene	Member Senior	нет	84.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #147
LeroyScheerman	Newbie	нет	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #148
Seybyst	Expert Senior	да	83.0	неизвестна	стр. 1, #149

Роли в снимке (8)

Administrator: 1
Connoisseur: 30
Expert Junior: 22
Expert Senior: 64
Member Junior: 14
Member Senior: 36
Newbie: 5
Super Administrator: 2

Источник — append-only снимки S3 (core_vote_snapshot/core_vote_row). Режимы ничего не записывают: страница только читает и не запускает сбор.

Избранное	Бутылка	Цена	WB рейтинг	Регион / дистиллерия	Скидка	WA медиана	vs WA	Fair€	vs fair	Маркет WB	vs маркет	Наличие	Тип / объём	Магазин	WB связь
	Macallan Classic Cut Limited 2023 Edition 50.3% ABV exBourbon + Sherry seasoned Whiskybase 70 cl	103.89 € 192 €	WB 86.7 173 оц. собр. 174/174	—Macallan	+45.9%	91.38 € 90.29 €–99.85 € · 5 из 32	-13.7%	111.00 €	+6.4%	109.00 €	+4.7%	в наличии	spirituosen70 cl	inn-out-shop	WB #236265 не подтверждено (не exact)